Team-EnderIO/EnderIO

Fork 0

XP Obelisk doesn't pull fluid XP from attached tank, unless externally triggered #904

New issue

Closed

opened 2024-11-30 16:43:51 +00:00 by Jack-McKalling · 6 comments

Jack-McKalling commented

2024-11-30 16:43:51 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Is there an existing issue for this?

I did not find any existing issues.

Current Behavior

When setting the XP obelisk to pull from an adjacent tank, it only starts actually filling once the tank it is attached to has pushed into it once before.

Expected Behavior

When turning the appropriate side config of the xp obelisk to "push" mode, I expected it to start filling up regardless of the tank's own mode.

Assuming the tank allows transferring on that side.

How to Test

Place a Fluid cell from the Thermal Series
Add a creative tank construction upgrade for simplification
Right-click an XP Juice Bucket onto the cell to fill it up with Ender IO's version of experience
Open the fluid cell and configure it to output to the top (with auto push disabled)
Place an XP Obelisk on top of the cell
Configure the XP obelisk to pull from its bottom

Notice nothing happening.
When you quickly enable and disable the fluid cell's auto push mode, the fluid continues to transfer afterwards

Local Environment

Operating System: Windows
Java version: 17.0.8 64bit (according to F3)
Minecraft Version: 1.20.1
Version: EnderIO-1.20.1-6.2.2-beta-all
Modloader: Forge
Other Mods: Thermal Expansion + dependencies

Any Additional Information?

Also tested with other mod's version of experience, such as mob grinding utils. Also tested with other mod's tanks.
All same result.

### Is there an existing issue for this? - [x] I did not find any existing issues. ### Current Behavior When setting the XP obelisk to pull from an adjacent tank, it only starts actually filling once the tank it is attached to has pushed into it once before. ### Expected Behavior When turning the appropriate side config of the xp obelisk to "push" mode, I expected it to start filling up regardless of the tank's own mode. Assuming the tank allows transferring on that side. ### How to Test 1. Place a Fluid cell from the Thermal Series 2. Add a creative tank construction upgrade for simplification 3. Right-click an XP Juice Bucket onto the cell to fill it up with Ender IO's version of experience 4. Open the fluid cell and configure it to output to the top (with auto push disabled) 5. Place an XP Obelisk on top of the cell 6. Configure the XP obelisk to pull from its bottom Notice nothing happening. When you quickly enable and disable the fluid cell's auto push mode, the fluid continues to transfer afterwards ### Local Environment - **Operating System**: Windows - **Java version**: 17.0.8 64bit (according to F3) - **Minecraft Version**: 1.20.1 - **Version**: EnderIO-1.20.1-6.2.2-beta-all - **Modloader**: Forge - **Other Mods**: Thermal Expansion + dependencies ### Any Additional Information? Also tested with other mod's version of experience, such as mob grinding utils. Also tested with other mod's tanks. All same result.

Jack-McKalling commented

2024-11-30 20:45:33 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Tested fluid containers as well as experience fluids from these mods:

Ender IO
Industrial Foregoing
Mob grinding Utils
Thermal Expansion

But the repro steps should be as simple as using Ender IO's own Fluid Tank and XP Juice.

Tested fluid containers as well as experience fluids from these mods: - Ender IO - Industrial Foregoing - Mob grinding Utils - Thermal Expansion But the repro steps should be as simple as using Ender IO's own Fluid Tank and XP Juice.

CitiesXL2815 commented

2024-11-30 23:02:02 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

this maybe related to these following issues https://github.com/Team-EnderIO/EnderIO/issues/667 & https://github.com/Team-EnderIO/EnderIO/issues/674 we will look into this further

👍 1

Blackalf commented

2025-03-25 18:22:39 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

The same issue happens with the Soul Binder or both Fluid Tanks too, as long as no fluid is present inside the block's fluid container the pull function of the block doesn't seem to work.

I don't seem to be able to upload a video in here but the issue should be easily reproducible!

The same issue happens with the Soul Binder or both Fluid Tanks too, as long as no fluid is present inside the block's fluid container the pull function of the block doesn't seem to work. I don't seem to be able to upload a video in here but the issue should be easily reproducible!

Rover656 commented

2025-07-12 21:01:48 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

I regret to say that we no longer officially support Minecraft 1.20.1 - as such we will not be officially fixing this issue.

If any community member wishes to submit a pull request to address this issue, feel free to open a PR and we will review and merge it.

I will close outstanding 1.20.1 issues in a little while, to keep the issue list clear.

Thanks again for your report.

I regret to say that we no longer officially support Minecraft 1.20.1 - as such we will not be officially fixing this issue. If any community member wishes to submit a pull request to address this issue, feel free to open a PR and we will review and merge it. I will close outstanding 1.20.1 issues in a little while, to keep the issue list clear. Thanks again for your report.

Jack-McKalling commented

2025-07-13 06:48:02 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

But if this issue also affects 1.21, will you guys fix it for that version and onwards? Because I didn't test it in other versions, it may affect those.

Rover656 commented

2025-10-04 21:42:01 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Closing as 1.20.1 is no longer being maintained, and this issue is no longer present in 1.21.1.
Please see #1156 for more information.
Thanks!

Closing as 1.20.1 is no longer being maintained, and this issue is no longer present in 1.21.1. Please see #1156 for more information. Thanks!

👍 1